BenchScoutCBA ExpirationDay 18⌘ K

CFB · Sat, Nov 15 · Spartan Stadium

Penn State4-628 – 10Michigan StMichigan State3-7

Final

Team1234T
PSU7701428
MSU730010

Who did you have?

No picks yet

Picking closed when the game did.

Top performers

Kaytron AllenPSU25 CAR, 181 YDS, 2 TDDevonte RossPSU2 REC, 79 YDS, 2 TDElijah Tau-TolliverMSU6 CAR, 79 YDS, 1 TD

Highlights (4)

▶ Devonte Ross scores second TD for Penn State

0:27 · MLB video

▶ Kaytron Allen walks it in for another Penn State TD

0:23 · MLB video

▶ Devonte Ross hauls in a 75-yard Penn State TD

0:40 · MLB video

▶ Elijah Tau-Tolliver scores 57-yard TD on Michigan State's first play from scrimmage

0:27 · MLB video

Play-by-play

158 plays

P1#29 M.Connington kickoff 65 yards to the PSU00, Touchback0–0
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 4 yards gain to the PSU29 (#14 M.Bell)0–0
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 2 yards gain to the PSU31 (#13 I.Smith)0–0
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush middle for 10 yards loss to the PSU21 fumbled by #17 E.Grunkemeyer at PSU26 recovered by PSU #17 E.Grunkemeyer at PSU24 (#14 M.Bell)0–0
P1#99 G.Nwosu punt 36 yards to the MSU43 fair catch by #1 O.Kelly at MSU430–0
P1Shotgun #4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush right for 57 yards gain to the PSU00 TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:46, 1ST DOWN #29 M.Connington kick attempt good (H: #96 R.Eckley, LS: #87 J.Wills)0–7
P1Timeout Michigan State, clock 12:460–7
P1#29 M.Connington kickoff 61 yards to the PSU04 #10 N.Singleton return 21 yards to the PSU25 (#30 A.Grose)0–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short left to #13 K.Allen caught at PSU22, for 5 yards to the PSU30 (#5 J.Hall; #23 D.Snow)0–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short right to #8 T.Pena caught at PSU35, for 7 yards to the PSU37 (#23 D.Snow), 1ST DOWN0–7
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 9 yards gain to the PSU46 (#19 A.Smith)0–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush middle for 0 yards to the PSU46 (#44 C.Williams; #91 A.VanSumeren)0–7
P1#13 K.Allen rush middle for 1 yard gain to the PSU47 (#14 M.Bell; #91 A.VanSumeren), 1ST DOWN0–7
P1Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush right for 4 yards gain to the MSU49 (#23 D.Snow)0–7
P1Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 3 yards gain to the MSU46 (#88 R.Buckley)0–7
P1Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush left for 1 yard gain to the MSU45 (#93 J.Satchell; #10 W.Matthews)0–7
P1#17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short right to #8 T.Pena caught at MSU45, for 7 yards to the MSU38 (#43 M.Spencer), 1ST DOWN0–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short middle to #8 T.Pena caught at MSU19, for 25 yards to the MSU13 (#19 A.Smith), 1ST DOWN0–7
P1No Huddle-Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 5 yards gain to the MSU08 (#16 G.Kelly; #43 M.Spencer)0–7
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 8 yards gain to the MSU00 TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:50, 1ST DOWN #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky) #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky) PENALTY #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky) PENALTY PSU UNS: Unsportsmanlike Conduct offsetting #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky) PENALTY PSU UNS: Unsportsmanlike Conduct offsetting MSU UNS: Unsportsmanlike Conduct offsetting7–7
P1Timeout Penn State, clock 05:507–7
P1#99 G.Nwosu kickoff 65 yards to the MSU00, Touchback7–7
P1Shotgun #4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush middle for 2 yards gain to the MSU27 (#24 A.Campbell; #50 A.Ford Jr.)7–7
P1Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #1 O.Kelly caught at MSU31, for 4 yards to the MSU31, out of bounds at MSU317–7
P1Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short right to #6 N.Marsh thrown to MSU47 QB hurried by #0 D.DeLuca7–7
P1#96 R.Eckley punt 48 yards to the PSU21 #8 T.Pena return 19 yards to the PSU40 (#34 K.Majeed) PENALTY PSU Holding (#33 D.Dennis-Sutton) 10 yards from PSU21 to PSU117–7
P1Timeout Michigan State, clock 04:257–7
P1Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 3 yards gain to the PSU14 (#91 A.VanSumeren; #99 Q.Dunnigan)7–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass incomplete short left to #10 N.Singleton thrown to PSU11 QB hurried by #93 J.Satchell7–7
P1Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass incomplete short left to #85 L.Reynolds thrown to PSU32 QB hurried by #99 Q.Dunnigan7–7
P1#99 G.Nwosu punt 39 yards to the MSU47 #1 O.Kelly return 8 yards to the PSU45 (#9 E.Washington II)7–7
P1Timeout Penn State, clock 03:197–7
P1#5 M.Frazier rush left for 5 yards gain to the PSU40 (#0 D.DeLuca; #24 A.Campbell)7–7
P1Shotgun #5 M.Frazier rush middle for 3 yards gain to the PSU37 (#24 A.Campbell)7–7
P1Shotgun #5 M.Frazier rush middle for 1 yard loss to the PSU38 (#16 K.Mack; #0 D.DeLuca)7–7
P1Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short right to #13 C.McCray thrown to PSU40 broken up by #5 D.Dixson QB hurried by #33 D.Dennis-Sutton, TURNOVER ON DOWNS7–7
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush right for 8 yards gain to the PSU46 (#10 W.Matthews)7–7
P1Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 3 yards gain to the PSU49 (#91 A.VanSumeren; #19 A.Smith), 1ST DOWN7–7
P1End of 1st quarter.7–7
P2Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 8 yards gain to the MSU43 (#99 Q.Dunnigan)7–7
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass incomplete short left to #1 K.Hudson thrown to MSU25 broken up by #19 A.Smith7–7
P2Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush right for 1 yard gain to the MSU42 (#99 Q.Dunnigan; #19 A.Smith)7–7
P2#10 N.Singleton rush middle for 0 yards to the MSU42 (#10 W.Matthews; #16 G.Kelly), TURNOVER ON DOWNS7–7
P2Timeout Penn State, clock 13:277–7
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU39, for 4 yards to the MSU46 (#50 A.Ford Jr.)7–7
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #6 N.Marsh caught at MSU49, for 3 yards to the MSU49 (#5 D.Dixson)7–7
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short right to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at PSU32, for 32 yards to the PSU19 (#7 Z.Tracy), 1ST DOWN7–7
P2#4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush middle for 11 yards gain to the PSU08 (#5 D.Dixson; #32 K.Wylie), 1ST DOWN7–7
P2#5 M.Frazier rush middle for 1 yard loss to the PSU09 (#32 K.Wylie; #5 D.Dixson)7–7
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short right to #81 M.Masunas caught at PSU04, for 5 yards to the PSU04 (#16 K.Mack)7–7
P2Timeout Michigan State, clock 09:277–7
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic sacked for loss of 2 yards to the PSU06 (#32 K.Wylie)7–7
P2#29 M.Connington field goal attempt from 24 yards GOOD (H: #96 R.Eckley, LS: #87 J.Wills), clock 08:407–10
P2Timeout Michigan State, clock 08:407–10
P2#29 M.Connington kickoff 65 yards to the PSU00, Touchback7–10
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short middle to #5 D.Ross caught at PSU31, for 75 yards to the MSU00 TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:30, 1ST DOWN #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky)14–10
P2#99 G.Nwosu kickoff 65 yards to the MSU00, Touchback14–10
P2Shotgun #4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush left for 0 yards to the MSU25 (#39 T.Blanding; #36 Z.Fisher)14–10
P2#11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short right to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU17, for 1 yard to the MSU26 (#2 A.Collins)14–10
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #1 O.Kelly caught at MSU31, for 6 yards to the MSU32 (#9 E.Washington II)14–10
P2#96 R.Eckley punt 9 yards to the MSU41 blocked by #33 D.Dennis-Sutton14–10
P2Timeout Michigan State, clock 06:0914–10
P2Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush left for 1 yard loss to the MSU42 (#10 W.Matthews)14–10
P2Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 8 yards gain to the MSU34 (#19 A.Smith)14–10
P2Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 2 yards gain to the MSU32 (#13 I.Smith; #5 J.Hall)14–10
P2Timeout Michigan State, clock 04:0314–10
P2Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 2 yards gain to the MSU30 (#43 M.Spencer; #16 G.Kelly), 1ST DOWN14–10
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short left to #13 K.Allen caught at MSU34, for 5 yards to the MSU25 (#23 D.Snow)14–10
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass incomplete short left to #10 N.Singleton thrown to MSU2514–10
P2Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush right for 3 yards gain to the MSU22 (#14 M.Bell; #43 M.Spencer)14–10
P2Timeout Penn State, clock 02:0014–10
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer sacked for loss of 6 yards to the MSU28 (#16 G.Kelly, #9 J.Thompson), TURNOVER ON DOWNS14–10
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic rush middle for 16 yards gain to the MSU44 (#24 A.Campbell), 1ST DOWN14–10
P2No Huddle-Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU47, for 4 yards to the MSU48 (#24 A.Campbell)14–10
P2No Huddle-Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short right to #6 N.Marsh thrown to PSU40 QB hurried by #44 J.Harvey14–10
P2Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete deep right to #6 N.Marsh thrown to PSU1514–10
P2#96 R.Eckley punt 41 yards to the PSU1114–10
P2Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short right to #8 T.Pena caught at PSU08, for 1 yard loss to the PSU10 (#9 J.Thompson; #34 K.Majeed)14–10
P2End of 2nd quarter.14–10
P3#99 G.Nwosu kickoff 65 yards to the MSU00 fair catch by #13 C.McCray at MSU0014–10
P3#1 O.Kelly rush right for 9 yards gain to the MSU34 (#0 D.DeLuca)14–10
P3Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #81 M.Masunas caught at MSU41, for 14 yards to the MSU48 (#0 D.DeLuca), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3#7 B.Tullis rush middle for 6 yards gain to the PSU46 (#7 Z.Tracy)14–10
P3#11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete deep right to #6 N.Marsh thrown to PSU1014–10
P3Shotgun #5 M.Frazier rush middle for 3 yards loss to the PSU49 (#6 Z.Wheatley)14–10
P3#96 R.Eckley punt 40 yards to the PSU09 fair catch by #8 T.Pena at PSU0914–10
P3Timeout Michigan State, clock 12:1914–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 4 yards gain to the PSU13 (#91 A.VanSumeren)14–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 7 yards gain to the PSU20 (#91 A.VanSumeren; #10 W.Matthews), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 0 yards to the PSU20 (#9 J.Thompson)14–10
P3Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass incomplete short middle to #85 L.Reynolds thrown to PSU25 broken up by #10 W.Matthews14–10
P3Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer sacked for loss of 6 yards to the PSU14 (#93 J.Satchell, #41 D.Santiago)14–10
P3#99 G.Nwosu punt 68 yards to the MSU18 #1 O.Kelly return 4 yards to the MSU22 (#9 E.Washington II)14–10
P3Timeout Penn State, clock 09:1514–10
P3Shotgun #4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush middle for 3 yards gain to the MSU25 (#24 A.Campbell)14–10
P3Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short right to #6 N.Marsh thrown to MSU30 QB hurried by #6 Z.Wheatley14–10
P3Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short middle to #6 N.Marsh thrown to MSU4014–10
P3#96 R.Eckley punt 58 yards to the PSU17 #8 T.Pena return 0 yards to the PSU17 (#30 A.Grose)14–10
P3Timeout Michigan State, clock 08:2714–10
P3Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush middle for 5 yards gain to the PSU22, End Of Play14–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 12 yards gain to the PSU34 (#5 J.Hall), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush left for 14 yards gain to the PSU48 (#14 M.Bell), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 5 yards gain to the MSU47 (#88 R.Buckley)14–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 1 yard gain to the MSU46 (#93 J.Satchell)14–10
P3Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 1 yard gain to the MSU45 (#9 J.Thompson; #10 W.Matthews)14–10
P3#99 G.Nwosu punt 41 yards to the MSU0414–10
P3Shotgun #5 M.Frazier rush middle for 9 yards gain to the MSU13 (#16 K.Mack; #6 Z.Wheatley)14–10
P3#5 M.Frazier rush right for 4 yards gain to the MSU17 (#24 A.Campbell), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3#5 M.Frazier rush left for 11 yards gain to the MSU28 (#32 K.Wylie), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3#11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #6 N.Marsh caught at MSU27, for 2 yards to the MSU30 (#2 A.Collins), out of bounds14–10
P3Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #81 M.Masunas caught at MSU40, for 10 yards to the MSU40 (#10 D.Lane), 1ST DOWN14–10
P3Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MSU33 (#33 D.Dennis-Sutton)14–10
P3PENALTY MSU Illegal Snap (#51 M.Gulbin) 5 yards from MSU33 to MSU28. NO PLAY14–10
P3End of 3rd quarter.14–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic sacked for loss of 8 yards to the MSU20 (#33 D.Dennis-Sutton)14–10
P4Shotgun #4 E.Tau-Tolliver rush middle for 6 yards gain to the MSU26 (#54 X.Gilliam)14–10
P4#96 R.Eckley punt 55 yards to the PSU19 #8 T.Pena return 5 yards to the PSU24 (#20 K.Williams)14–10
P4Timeout Michigan State, clock 13:3714–10
P4Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush middle for 9 yards gain to the PSU33, End Of Play14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 2 yards gain to the PSU35 (#5 J.Hall; #91 A.VanSumeren), 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush right for 6 yards gain to the PSU41 (#10 W.Matthews; #91 A.VanSumeren)14–10
P4Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 4 yards gain to the PSU45 (#99 Q.Dunnigan), 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 12 yards gain to the MSU43 (#43 M.Spencer; #14 M.Bell), 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush right for 4 yards gain to the MSU39 (#13 I.Smith; #16 G.Kelly)14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 6 yards gain to the MSU33 (#23 D.Snow), 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush right for 8 yards gain to the MSU25 (#14 M.Bell)14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 6 yards gain to the MSU19 (#10 W.Matthews), 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer rush right for 10 yards gain to the MSU09, End Of Play, 1ST DOWN14–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 4 yards gain to the MSU05 (#93 J.Satchell)14–10
P4Shotgun #10 N.Singleton rush middle for 1 yard gain to the MSU04 (#13 I.Smith; #16 G.Kelly)14–10
P4Shotgun #17 E.Grunkemeyer pass complete short middle to #5 D.Ross caught at MSU07, for 4 yards to the MSU00 TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:32 #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky)21–10
P4Timeout Penn State, clock 04:3221–10
P4#99 G.Nwosu kickoff 65 yards to the MSU00 fair catch by #13 C.McCray at MSU0021–10
P4#11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU22, for 16 yards to the MSU41 (#6 Z.Wheatley), 1ST DOWN21–10
P4No Huddle-Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU43, for 4 yards to the MSU45 (#24 A.Campbell)21–10
P4No Huddle-Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #1 O.Kelly caught at MSU50, for 5 yards to the MSU50 (#5 D.Dixson; #16 K.Mack)21–10
P4PENALTY PSU Roughing The Passer (#36 Z.Fisher) 15 yards from MSU50 to PSU35, 1ST DOWN. NO PLAY21–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete deep left to #13 C.McCray thrown to PSU07, 1ST DOWN, PENALTY PSU Roughing The Passer (#33 D.Dennis-Sutton) 15 yards from PSU35 to PSU20, 1ST DOWN21–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic sacked for loss of 10 yards to the PSU30 (#7 Z.Tracy), fumble by #11 A.Milivojevic recovered by PSU #5 D.Dixson at PSU30, End Of Play21–10
P4Timeout Michigan State, clock 03:1521–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 2 yards gain to the PSU32 (#2 A.West; #23 D.Snow)21–10
P4Timeout Michigan State, clock 03:0921–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush middle for 42 yards gain to the MSU26 (#14 M.Bell), 1ST DOWN21–10
P4Shotgun #13 K.Allen rush left for 26 yards gain to the MSU00 TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:07, 1ST DOWN #94 R.Barker kick attempt good (H: #14 R.Thompson, LS: #48 T.Duzansky)28–10
P4PENALTY PSU Delay Of Game 5 yards from MSU03 to MSU08. NO PLAY27–10
P4#99 G.Nwosu kickoff 63 yards to the MSU02 fair catch by #13 C.McCray at MSU0228–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short middle to #12 J.Velling caught at MSU31, for 6 yards to the MSU31 (#16 K.Mack)28–10
P4Timeout Michigan State, clock 02:0028–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU24, for 5 yards to the MSU36 (#2 A.Collins), 1ST DOWN28–10
P4No Huddle-Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short right to #1 O.Kelly thrown to MSU46 QB hurried by #32 K.Wylie28–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass complete short left to #4 E.Tau-Tolliver caught at MSU38, for 7 yards to the MSU43 (#5 D.Dixson)28–10
P4PENALTY MSU UNS: Unsportsmanlike Conduct (#4 E.Tau-Tolliver) 15 yards from MSU43 to MSU28. NO PLAY28–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic pass incomplete short middle to #8 E.Boyd thrown to MSU45 broken up by #9 E.Washington II QB hurried by #45 E.White28–10
P4Shotgun #11 A.Milivojevic sacked for loss of 9 yards to the MSU19 (#24 A.Campbell, #16 K.Mack), TURNOVER ON DOWNS28–10
P4Kneel down by Penn St. at MSU21 for loss of 2 yards28–10
P4Kneel down by Penn St. at MSU22 for loss of 1 yard28–10
P4Timeout Michigan State, clock 01:1428–10
P4End of 4th quarter.28–10

Box score

PSU 28 · MSU 10

Pat Fitzgerald MSU

Passing

PlayerC/ATTYDSAVGTDINTQBR
Ethan Grunkemeyer8/131279.82051.6

Rushing

PlayerCARYDSAVGTDLONG
Kaytron Allen251817.2242
Nicholas Singleton15563.7014
Ethan Grunkemeyer860.8010
Team2-3-1.500

Receiving

PlayerRECYDSAVGTDLONG
Trebor Pena4389.5025
Devonte Ross27939.5275
Kaytron Allen2105.005

Fumbles

PlayerFUMLOSTREC
Team100
Ethan Grunkemeyer100
Daryus Dixson001

Defense

PlayerTOTSOLOSACKSTFLPDTDQB HUR
Amare Campbell960.50.5000
King Mack620.51000
Daryus Dixson5200.5100
Dominic DeLuca4200.5001
Keon Wylie4211.5001
Audavion Collins3300000
Elliot Washington II3300100
Zakee Wheatley3201001
Zion Tracy3311000
Alonzo Ford Jr.2100000
Dani Dennis-Sutton2222001
Dejuan Lane1100000
Ty Blanding1000000
Xavier Gilliam1100000
Zuriah Fisher1000000
Enai White0000001
Jaylen Harvey0000001

Kick returns

PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Nicholas Singleton12121.0210

Punt returns

PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Trebor Pena3248.0190

Kicking

PlayerFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Ryan Barker0/00.004/44

Punting

PlayerNOYDSAVGTBIn 20LONG
Gabriel Nwosu418446.00168

Betting

No odds for this game yet.

Gamethread

Nobody yet

Log in to join the thread. Nobody has said anything yet.