BenchScoutOctober BaseballDay 34Search teams, players, games/

St. Louis Cardinals at Philadelphia Phillies

MLBMay 12, 2025Citizens Bank Park

CardinalsSt. LouisSTLWon23-19

Cardinals 3, Phillies 2

Final
PhilliesPhiladelphiaPHI24-17
Score by inning
Team123456789RHE
STL000101100350
PHI000101000290

W Kyle LeahyL Matt StrahmSV Ryan Helsley

Scoring

Play-by-play

In order

Top 1st

  1.  Lars Nootbaar lines out to first baseman Bryce Harper.
  2.  Masyn Winn strikes out on a foul tip.
  3.  Brendan Donovan hit by pitch.
  4.  Nolan Arenado lines out to center fielder Johan Rojas.

Bot 1st

  1.  Trea Turner strikes out swinging.
  2.  Bryce Harper strikes out swinging.
  3.  Kyle Schwarber grounds out, second baseman Brendan Donovan to first baseman Willson Contreras.

Top 2nd

  1.  Willson Contreras doubles (7) on a sharp line drive to center fielder Johan Rojas.STL 57%
  2.  Iván Herrera strikes out swinging.STL 52%
  3.  Pedro Pagés strikes out swinging.
  4.  Jordan Walker strikes out swinging.

Bot 2nd

  1.  Nick Castellanos singles on a ground ball to left fielder Lars Nootbaar.PHI 60%
  2.  J.T. Realmuto lines out sharply to center fielder José Barrero.
  3.  Alec Bohm lines out sharply to center fielder José Barrero.
  4.  Edmundo Sosa grounds out sharply, third baseman Nolan Arenado to first baseman Willson Contreras.

Top 3rd

  1.  José Barrero grounds out, second baseman Edmundo Sosa to first baseman Bryce Harper.
  2.  Lars Nootbaar singles on a line drive to left fielder Weston Wilson.
  3.  Masyn Winn lines out sharply to center fielder Johan Rojas.
  4.  Brendan Donovan called out on strikes.

Bot 3rd

  1.  Weston Wilson strikes out swinging.
  2.  Johan Rojas flies out to center fielder José Barrero.
  3.  Trea Turner singles on a ground ball to left fielder Lars Nootbaar.
  4.  Bryce Harper walks. Trea Turner to 2nd.
  5.  Kyle Schwarber flies out to left fielder Lars Nootbaar.

Top 4th

  1.  Nolan Arenado walks.STL 55%
  2.  Cardinals challenged (tag play), call on the field was overturned: Willson Contreras flies out to center fielder Johan Rojas. Nolan Arenado to 2nd.
  3.  Iván Herrera walks. Nolan Arenado to 3rd. Wild pitch by pitcher Cristopher Sánchez. Nolan Arenado to 3rd.STL 58%
  4.  Pedro Pagés grounds into a force out, third baseman Alec Bohm to second baseman Edmundo Sosa. Nolan Arenado scores. Iván Herrera out at 2nd. Pedro Pagés to 1st.
  5.  Jordan Walker lines out to second baseman Edmundo Sosa.

Bot 4th

  1.  Nick Castellanos flies out to center fielder José Barrero.
  2.  J.T. Realmuto doubles (7) on a line drive to left fielder Lars Nootbaar.STL 55%
  3.  Alec Bohm grounds out, second baseman Brendan Donovan to first baseman Willson Contreras. J.T. Realmuto to 3rd.
  4.  Edmundo Sosa singles on a ground ball to third baseman Nolan Arenado. J.T. Realmuto scores.PHI 53%
  5.  Weston Wilson flies out to right fielder Jordan Walker.

Top 5th

  1.  José Barrero grounds out, second baseman Edmundo Sosa to first baseman Bryce Harper.
  2.  Lars Nootbaar singles on a ground ball to second baseman Edmundo Sosa, deflected by pitcher Cristopher Sánchez.
  3.  Masyn Winn walks. Lars Nootbaar to 2nd.STL 56%
  4.  Brendan Donovan grounds out to first baseman Bryce Harper. Lars Nootbaar to 3rd. Masyn Winn to 2nd.
  5.  Nolan Arenado flies out to second baseman Edmundo Sosa.PHI 56%

Bot 5th

  1.  Johan Rojas flies out to right fielder Jordan Walker.
  2.  Trea Turner strikes out swinging.
  3.  Bryce Harper grounds out, first baseman Willson Contreras to pitcher Matthew Liberatore.

Top 6th

  1.  Willson Contreras strikes out swinging.
  2.  Iván Herrera homers (5) on a line drive to right center field.STL 62%
  3.  Pedro Pagés strikes out swinging.
  4.  Jordan Walker strikes out swinging.

Bot 6th

  1.  Kyle Schwarber singles on a line drive to center fielder José Barrero.STL 52%
  2.  Nick Castellanos singles on a fly ball to center fielder José Barrero. Kyle Schwarber to 3rd.PHI 62%
  3.  J.T. Realmuto grounds into a force out, third baseman Nolan Arenado to second baseman Brendan Donovan. Kyle Schwarber scores. Nick Castellanos out at 2nd. J.T. Realmuto to 1st.
  4.  Alec Bohm singles on a line drive to right fielder Jordan Walker. J.T. Realmuto to 2nd.PHI 65%
  5.  Bryson Stott flies out to center fielder José Barrero. J.T. Realmuto to 3rd.PHI 58%
  6.  Max Kepler grounds out to first baseman Willson Contreras.PHI 52%

Top 7th

  1.  José Barrero strikes out swinging.
  2.  Lars Nootbaar lines out to right fielder Nick Castellanos.
  3.  Masyn Winn homers (4) on a fly ball to left center field.STL 61%
  4.  Brendan Donovan lines out sharply to left fielder Max Kepler.

Bot 7th

  1.  Brandon Marsh strikes out swinging.
  2.  Trea Turner flies out to center fielder Victor Scott II.
  3.  Bryce Harper called out on strikes.

Top 8th

  1.  Nolan Arenado pops out to first baseman Bryce Harper.
  2.  Willson Contreras called out on strikes.
  3.  Iván Herrera grounds out, shortstop Trea Turner to first baseman Bryce Harper.

Bot 8th

  1.  Kyle Schwarber grounds out, second baseman Brendan Donovan to first baseman Willson Contreras.
  2.  Nick Castellanos grounds out, shortstop Masyn Winn to first baseman Willson Contreras.
  3.  J.T. Realmuto singles on a sharp line drive to center fielder Victor Scott II.
  4.  Alec Bohm singles on a sharp line drive to center fielder Victor Scott II. J.T. Realmuto to 2nd.STL 64%
  5.  Bryson Stott flies out to left fielder Lars Nootbaar.STL 72%

Top 9th

  1.  Pedro Pagés grounds out to first baseman Bryce Harper.
  2.  Jordan Walker flies out to right fielder Nick Castellanos.
  3.  Victor Scott II flies out to left fielder Max Kepler.

Bot 9th

  1.  Max Kepler strikes out swinging.STL 75%
  2.  Brandon Marsh called out on strikes.STL 81%
  3.  Trea Turner lines out to right fielder Jordan Walker.

Top 4th

  1.  STL 1, PHI 0Pedro Pagés grounds into a force out, third baseman Alec Bohm to second baseman Edmundo Sosa. Nolan Arenado scores. Iván Herrera out at 2nd. Pedro Pagés to 1st.

Bot 4th

  1.  STL 1, PHI 1Edmundo Sosa singles on a ground ball to third baseman Nolan Arenado. J.T. Realmuto scores.PHI 53%

Top 6th

  1.  STL 2, PHI 1Iván Herrera homers (5) on a line drive to right center field.STL 62%

Bot 6th

  1.  STL 2, PHI 2J.T. Realmuto grounds into a force out, third baseman Nolan Arenado to second baseman Brendan Donovan. Kyle Schwarber scores. Nick Castellanos out at 2nd. J.T. Realmuto to 1st.

Top 7th

  1.  STL 3, PHI 2Masyn Winn homers (4) on a fly ball to left center field.STL 61%

Win probability

Top 7th · Biggest swing #1 · STL 3–2 PHI

Masyn Winn homers (4) on a fly ball to left center field.

See it in the scoring summary
STL 61%STL +19 pts

Game leaders

CardinalsSt. Louis

PhilliesPhiladelphia

Box score

BattingABRHRBIHRBBSOAVG
Lars Nootbaar LF4020000.250
Masyn Winn SS3111111.255
Brendan Donovan 2B3000001.312
Nolan Arenado 3B3100010.264
Willson Contreras 1B4010002.255
Iván Herrera DH3111111.355
Pedro Pagés C4001002.235
Jordan Walker RF4000002.180
José Barrero CF3000001.188
Victor Scott II CF1000000.288
Totals323532310

2B: Contreras.HR: Winn, Herrera.RBI: Winn, Herrera, Pagés.

PitchingIPHRERBBSOPERA
Matthew Liberatore5.172214803.11
Kyle Leahy W2.120002351.09
JoJo Romero0.10000025.25
Ryan Helsley S1.000002133.00

Video

2:51Cardinals vs. Phillies HighlightsMLB video
1:44Cristopher Sánchez sets down eight Cardinals0:11JoJo Romero escapes trouble in 8th0:59Nolan Arenado takes second after review0:12Cristopher Sánchez escapes jam in 5th
All 21 clips

Gamethread

Anyone can read the thread; posting needs an account.Log in to post